Thank you @Scott Johnson and @Henry Boardman for reaching out. Both of you were right. I had to read the white paper multiple times and I still missed it. As I read through the White paper I found a section called Standard, Interactive and Non-Interactive Authentication. In that section and several other section that talked about multiple logon configurations, the first step was '1. Configure the Web Server and associated virtual directory for autologon (see Appendix A).' Followed by steps to setup the other types of logons. I went to Appendix A and setup the Directories and Web.configs per suggestions however to no avail.
We requested a solution Consultant who pointed out page 47 - 49 of the White paper document labeled 'Front-facing Web Applications on the Same Machine as the Application Server' . Our web and App server are indeed on the same server for pre-prod. Once she went through the steps, I was able to log on Non-Interactively
Thank you again for helping point me to the right direction and I hope someone else finds this useful.
