Thank you for the response,
I kind of figured that this was the case, but I'm glad it's confirmed. I guess my problem lies in the migration in general. I'm looking the logs, and the only one that I think is causing problems when trying to log in is "unable to retrieve license from server 404" error alfresco.log. I'm not sure what's causing this error; I tried disabling the firewall temporarily to see if it was that type of issue, but I received the same error regardless.
When opening a browser after restarting the Alfresco service, the login screen automatically generates the error "The remote server may be unavailable or your authentication details have not been recognized" before even trying to log in. I'm thinking this might be why it's not indexing. Thanks!