topic Re: CIFS and FTP service too slow in Alfresco Archive

CIFS and FTP service too slow

miguel_gil_mart — Thu, 29 Jun 2006 16:07:18 GMT

Hello!!!I have Alfresco-1.3 Tomcat final in a 3.0Ghz P4 HT with 2Gb RAM and a fast 160Gb HDD SATA2.Linux Mandriva 2006. Alfresco dedicated Server. SQL in other dedicated machine, in a similar hardware configuration.Tomcat's logs warn nothing wrong.JAVA_OPT Xmx: 1536mIt has over 4.000 files (pdf) in

Re: CIFS and FTP service too slow

gary_spencer — Thu, 06 Jul 2006 15:05:32 GMT

Hi,

The CIFS and FTP server code uses a cut down version of the JLAN Server code but the majority of the protocol code is the same.

I have some benchmarks of the JLAN Server code here - http://www.starlasoft.com/jlansrv/benchmarks.html. The latest 3.6 code should be about 30% quicker on the CIFS test when using the new Winsock NetBIOS JNI code.

Cheers

Gary

Re: CIFS and FTP service too slow

miguel_gil_mart — Fri, 07 Jul 2006 07:37:40 GMT

Ok, ok. It is not an Open Source code…. ummmm :cry: . It makes Alfresco CIFS service unusable for medium-large enterprises. Do we have to wait 1.4 out ? What can we do it?

Thanks!!!!!

Re: CIFS and FTP service too slow

paulhh — Fri, 07 Jul 2006 16:43:44 GMT

There are a number of things we're doing on performance in 1.4. Also, there is a lot you can do on the configuration to change the performance profile. If you're using it in a medium-large enterprise, you could always consider getting support - then it would encourage us to get it working well for you 🙂

What is the scenario for very large numbers of being copied over? Is it something that happens regularly as well as "standard" user interaction with the client? Is it an overnight task?

Cheers
Paul.

Re: CIFS and FTP service too slow

miguel_gil_mart — Mon, 10 Jul 2006 06:38:03 GMT

My scenario is:
- 35.000 PDF's, over 30Kb each one, stored in folders and subfolders, max. 600 items/folder.
- 100 users, uploading, downloading, editing….. using Alfresco!!!.
- Increasing number of docs, between 200 and 500 per day.
- Access via CIFS-WEBDAV-FTP for uploading (we'll choose the faster protocol) and web client for searching and editing online.

We are in testing stage. We cannot use CIFS-WEBDAV-FTP because space listing is really slow. We are considering to freeze project until 1.4

Cheers
Miguel.

Re: CIFS and FTP service too slow

jarek_potiuk — Mon, 10 Jul 2006 08:03:53 GMT

We have slightly less than that (ca. 15.000 - 18.000 files and we do not experience problems with performance - well WEB is certainly fastest, webdav slightly slower and cifs being slowest - though still quite OK). Usually listing of a directory takes <0.5-1 second.

One case where we did experience problems (I created JIRA issue for it - http://www.alfresco.org/jira/browse/AR-708 ) was when we had few 1000s of deleted files (they were all in the "undelete" space). Then ALL delete operations were TERRIBLY slow (up to 1 minute). Maybe that's the same case - the slowdown would occur when you have many objects in the same space. From the observation we had - the experiencable slowdown started somewhere between 500-1000 objects. Removal of >3000 files from the "undelete" spaces took ca. 40 hours but after we did it it went back to the normal speed.

My scenario is:
- 35.000 PDF's, over 30Kb each one, stored in folders and subfolders, max. 600 items/folder.
- 100 users, uploading, downloading, editing….. using Alfresco!!!.
- Increasing number of docs, between 200 and 500 per day.
- Access via CIFS-WEBDAV-FTP for uploading (we'll choose the faster protocol) and web client for searching and editing online.

We are in testing stage. We cannot use CIFS-WEBDAV-FTP because space listing is really slow. We are considering to freeze project until 1.4

Cheers
Miguel.