topic Re: Add comments on completed tasks in Alfresco Archive

Add comments on completed tasks

smartxiaofish — Mon, 28 Sep 2015 08:56:41 GMT

currently, add a comment on a task is attached on TaskService, and TaskService is operating on task that has not been finished. Comment org.activiti.engine.TaskService.addComment(String taskId, String processInstanceId, String message)‍‍‍I try to add a comment on a completed task, and it shows org.

Re: Add comments on completed tasks

martin_grofcik — Tue, 29 Sep 2015 08:15:57 GMT

Hi,

The problem is that task is runtime object. When the task is completed the row is deleted from runtime tables. That's why it is not possible to add comment to already deleted object.
There is still track of task in the history tables. (I am not keen on the idea to change history. 🙂 ). There is no API to change the history (only to delete object)

Regards
Martin

Re: Add comments on completed tasks

smartxiaofish — Wed, 30 Sep 2015 00:30:11 GMT

thanks for reply.
i understand why i can't add comment on finished( which is in history) task using TaskService.
but it seems that Comments are some kind of history objects, as its table named "act_hi_comment". and Comments are just a connection to historicTaskIntances. i guess there is no harm to add a comment to a finished task, especially a completed task. and actually in real world, i think sometimes we really need to comment on a task which has just been completed.

Re: Add comments on completed tasks

trademak — Wed, 30 Sep 2015 14:20:07 GMT

Right, that use case is valid of course. We currently only support adding comments on open tasks. So it would be a feature request to change this.

Best regards,